Every now and then modern medicine makes you go, “huh..who knew?” Never was there a more appropriate scenario than in the case of the poop-transplant. Taking another person’s crap and shoving it up your bum doesn’t seem like a worthwhile medical procedure, but in reality, this form of defecation sharing can save someone’s life. So drink some coffee, eat a bran muffin and read on to find out all about poop transplants. You too might be able to use your morning stool for good.
Known as Fecal Microbiota transplantation (FMT), the poop transplant isn’t as modern as you might think. It can trace its roots back to 4th century China where they used it for treating food poisoning and severe diarrhea. In the 16th century, the Chinese physician, Li Shizhen, used fresh, dried, or fermented feces to treat a number of abdominal diseases. He called it “yellow soup”. Mmm.. eat your heart out Campbell’s Chunky Chicken!
More recently the procedure has gained prominence because of how well it treats the rapidly growing problem of Clostridium difficile infection (C diff.) The gold-standard of treatment used to be giving someone with the affliction oral antibiotics. Specifically Vancomycin. Unfortunately, Vancomycin alone has a cure rate of only 23%-31%. FMT’s success rate in treating C diff. is 81% after the 1st administration and 94% after the second.
So what is it we’re actually doing by putting feces up people backsides?
The human gastrointestinal tract is home to a vast cornucopia of bacteria. It’s currently estimated that about 1,000,000,000,000,000, or 10 to the 14th power, bacterial cells reside in our bodies. Compared to 10 to the 13th power of human cells. That means inside your body, there’s more bacteria than there is you! Almost all of those bacterial cells reside in your GI tract.
Medical science hasn’t yet identified all of the specific types of bacteria, or what each’s particular role in the body is. What we do know is, each person has between 15,000 and 36,000 different bacterial species flourishing inside them.
The environment within your GI tract is a complex, yet balanced, system that helps breakdown many of the nutrients we take in. Their digestion of nutrients helps with everything from developing our immune systems and repressing the growth of harmful microorganisms, to breaking down Oligosaccharides. Oligosaccharides being the sugar molecules found in beans (and other fibers) that give you gas. The bacteria that breaks these down are only found in your large intestine.
When specific types of bacteria are missing from your digestive system, and therefore their beneficial results, various diseases can begin to present themselves. Things like C diff., irritable bowel syndrome, Crohn’s disease, and ulcerative colitis to name a few. The idea behind FMT is, should someone have a condition where they might be lacking in certain types of beneficial bacteria, take healthy poop from someone who does, and put it in their GI tract. Those bacteria will then grow and proliferate, thereby curing the individual of their affliction.
Current medical literature has shown there has been a quick rise in GI problems around the world. Specifically in developed countries where antibiotics are frequently used. The global epidemic of GI issues like C diff. has been long known to be a result of taking antibiotics. Dr. Maria Olivia-Hemker of John’s Hopkins Children Center states; “Antibiotics are lifesavers, but anytime we give them to a patient to eradicate one pathogen, there’s collateral damage, in that along with the bad bacteria we wipe off some good organisms that help keep the complex workings of our gut in perfect balance.” This ideology is also why many doctors advise taking probiotics after any antibiotic administration.
One of those bad bacteria that can propagate, should it not be kept in check, is the aforementioned Clostridium difficile. This bad bacteria can cause symptoms like watery diarrhea, fever, loss of appetite, nausea, and abdominal pain. The CDC estimates C diff. affected about 500,000 Americans in 2011. Of those, about 29,000 of them died within 30 days of their initial diagnosis.
The first randomized study on treating C diff with FMT was published in Jan of 2013. It showed an 81% resolution of C. diff. associated diarrhea after just the first infusion. These amazing, life-saving results made the medical world take notice. Maybe poop-pushing isn’t so crazy after all.
Never being ones to let anything in medicine go without their reviewing it, 3 months later in April, the FDA classified fecal transplants as both a biologic material as well as a drug. In this case, a new investigational drug. As such, it meant only doctors with an approved investigational drug application could perform the transplant. Given that in all of history there has never been any serious side effect of transplanting poop, you can imaging there was a crap-load (pun intended) of physicians and patients that opposed this position.
The FDA almost immediately reversed their stance and in June of that year, stated any qualified physician could perform the procedure if they got signed consent forms from their patients, and they tested the donor stool.
While it may seem asinine (again, pun intended) to classify poop as a “new investigational drug”, the FDA does have a point. There hasn’t ever been a large-scale, controlled trial showing any effect beyond restoring the diverse microbiota within the gut. Most doctors will tell you there needs to be more research demonstrating exactly what effects changing the complex make up of your bowels will have on overall health.
For instance, one follow-up study done by Dr. L. Brandt and his colleagues in 2012 showed, while the 77 patients in the study had no new C diff. infections, 4 of them presented with new disorders. Specifically, peripheral neuropathy, Sjögren’s disease, idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura, and rheumatoid arthritis. In 2011, a 32 year old women suddenly became obese after being treated with FMT.
These disorders might seem like they have nothing to do with your feces, given there are so many bodily functions and disease processes that can be affected by your gut bacteria, the findings only emphasizes the point, more research should be done before we just start taking poop-pills like its candy.
That being said, because the lack of a healthy digestive environment is linked to several types of illnesses, FMT has been proposed as a potential treatment for several conditions. Problems like obesity, metabolic syndrome, diabetes, multiple sclerosis, Parkinson’s, rheumatoid arthritis, chronic fatigue syndrome, irritable bowel syndrome, ulcerative colitis, and Crohns disease.
If you think you might want help someone out and take a dump in a petri dish during your next doctors’ visit? Don’t worry, there’s an organization out there helping make it possible. Called Openbiome, this non-profit stool bank aims to make FMT easier, cheaper, safer and more widely available. They do this by providing hospitals with screened, frozen material ready for clinical use. They’re currently providing over 400 healthcare institutions around the United States and Europe with healthy fecal matter.
More research and technological advances will undoubtedly show doctors what exactly the countless species of bacteria specifically do for our health and wellbeing. Until then, what we’re finding out is, introducing good bacteria in the form of peoples poop is saving lives. All I can say is, the next time someone tells me to eat-sh@t, I just might say… “Ok”!